Hello dear
Welcome to Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Wantagh
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Wantagh, located at 3430 Sunrise Hwy, serves up a delightful blend of robust flavors and inviting atmosphere. Renowned for their coal-fired chicken wings, these jumbo beauties come in various flavors, including Original and Buffalo. The menu also features al dente rigatoni with Maria's meatballs and an array of pizzas, from the classic Margherita to innovative combinations like Caprese. Guests rave about the bold sauce and fresh ingredients, with numerous reviews highlighting the attentive service and cozy vibe. Whether dining in or taking out, Anthony's promises a satisfying culinary experience that keeps patrons coming back for more.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Anthony's Classic Italian Salad
Caprese Pizza
Roasted Cauliflower Pizza
Carnivori Pizza
About
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Wantagh
At the heart of Wantagh, nestled along the bustling Sunrise Highway, lies a gem that promises a unique dining experience: Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings. Known for its commitment to fire-roasting perfection, Anthony's delivers a menu that is both classic and innovative, making it a beloved spot for locals and pizza enthusiasts alike.
One of the standout features here are the coal-fired chicken wings. These aren't just your run-of-the-mill wings; they are jumbo-sized, expertly prepared in a coal oven, and available in flavors like Original with caramelized onions, Dry Rub, Buffalo, and a zesty Garlic Romano. The pairing of wings with their freshly baked focaccia bread elevates this dish to new heights, ensuring a delightful experience with every bite.
The sandwiches at Anthony's also deserve a mention. The Italian Tuna Sandwich, featuring lemon, olive oil, tomato, and arugula drizzled with homemade Italian dressing on focaccia, is a refreshing choice. Meanwhile, the Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Sandwich, topped with prosciutto, roasted red peppers, and mozzarella, offers an explosion of flavor that is sure to please. For meatball lovers, the Long Hot Meatball Sandwich combines succulent meatballs with mozzarella and long hot finger peppers, creating a satisfying meal perfect for any occasion.
And let’s not forget dessert! Their NY Style Cheesecake is a must-try with its classic graham cracker crust—rich, creamy, and utterly divine.
The ambiance at Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings is just as inviting as the food. Many patrons, like Michael H, have praised the spacious interior and vibrant atmosphere, highlighting how even takeout can feel special in this setting. It's not uncommon for first-timers to be greeted with complimentary garlic knots, adding a personal touch that enhances the overall dining experience. Customer reviews echo the sentiment that the service is friendly and attentive, making each visit memorable.
Despite any criticism regarding the potential for slightly charred pizza, many diners, including Pedro Luis, have discovered that when cooked correctly, the pizza here is nothing short of phenomenal. The bold, flavorful sauces and quality ingredients create a harmonious blend that is hard to resist.
In addition to its culinary delights, Anthony's has a reward program that keeps customers coming back for more, offering incentives like free pizzas. Whether you're dining in or taking out, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Wantagh is a destination that promises delicious food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere.
So, if you're in the Wantagh area and craving a truly mouthwatering pizza or wings experience, don't hesitate to visit Anthony's. Your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I saw some negative comments about the pizza being burnt and what not but I gave it a shot anyway and this is the best pizza I’ve tasted so far. Cooked to perfection and tastes, absolutely fresh. I’m sure the guys probably have some off days once in a blue for those complaining about anything. ”
“ I ordered some takeout for myself online and went to pick it up. Got a 12" square margherita pie, a small Caesar salad, and a side of Romano focaccia bread. Everything was great! The pizza was delicious - very bold, flavorful sauce. The salad was very good, loved the dressing and the homemade croutons were amazing! Lastly, the focaccia bread which I ordered on a whim, ended up really impressing me! Even though I did takeout, I have to say the inside of this place has a cool atmosphere, it's nice and spacious, and they have a cool looking bar. ”
“ Delicious food and great service. We went on Sunday in the early afternoon and we had the whole restaurant to ourselves. The waitress brought us two garlic knots since it was our first time. We ordered garlic romano wings for appetizer and the Carnivori pizza. The food was amazing. ”
“ I love this place! Their food is amazing and the atmosphere and service are just incredible. ”
“ Really enjoy going here. The food is so good. Like their reward program. Got a free pizza. The best. ”
“ Your kitchen manager, Jack...he is a keeper! The waitress was gr8. Was a very delicious meal...pizza, meatball, garlic knots & chicken wings with the caramelized onions with that flamed flavor to chicken skin. Very memorable...I will be back! Thanks for making me feel at home... Regards, Al ”
“ Our waitress was so nice and attentive. I wish I remembered her name. She gave great suggestions on drinks and had the bartender make an amazing espresso martini. The food was fresh and delicious. The wings are amazing Definitely recommend after a beach day. ”
“ UPDATE: We gave this location another try via GrubHub and I have to give them 5 Stars***. Ordered a Create your own 12" with Mushrooms, Ricotta, Extra sauce and Basil and I will tell you it is the absolute best brick oven pizza I have had anywhere in New York! It weighed a ton and was absolutely delicious! Bravo to whoever created this masterpiece! __________________________________________ I order from this restaurant quite often on GrubHub and it's always great. When I found myself waiting for a train to come in I decided to try it in person. It was awful! First of all the person who seats you also takes phone orders, and even though she's making eye contact with you, the phone is her priority. The atmosphere is very loud, very uncomfortable, and the old Ground Round immediately came to mind, including the kids and the baby strollers. I ordered the same items that I get on GH and it was horrible! The tomatoes in the salad were rock hard and mostly white. They should never have been served. The Eggplant Marino is always enough for 2 but was a very small portion, maybe 3" across and cold. The focaccia was scorched and not in a good way. Tasted like dirty oven. Service was as good as it could be under the overcrowded circumstances. I'll continue to order on GH, but this wasn't a pleasant dinner experience at all. ”